Chambersburg

Fayetteville

Greencastle

Waynesboro

Hagerstown

Roxbury

Biglerville

Orrtanna

Mont Alto

Shippensburg

Havre De Grace

Newburg

Mercersburg

Mc Connellsburg

Chambersburg

Cara Sheaffer

RE/MAX 1st Advantage

Cara Sheaffer

RE/MAX 1st Advantage

$248kmedian price

46homes sold

26buyer transactions

Cara Sheaffer's Top Cities

Listings closed in the past 24 months

Chambersburg42

Fayetteville8

Greencastle7

Waynesboro3

Hagerstown2

Saint Thomas2

Roxbury1

Biglerville1

Orrtanna1

Mont Alto1

Camp Hill1

Shippensburg1

East Berlin1

Havre De Grace1

Newburg1

Mercersburg1

Mc Connellsburg1

Are you Cara Sheaffer? Claim your profile.

Is Cara Sheaffer the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Cara scores for your buying or selling needs

Get Started

Performance Summary

Since March 2022, Cara Sheaffer has closed 46 transactions representing homeowners, and 26 transactions representing buyers with a total production value of $21M and a median price of $215k. Most of Cara Sheaffer's transactions are single family homes.

Pennsylvania

Maryland

Select a market segment:

All Property Types

All Price Ranges

$300k or less

$300k-$600k

$1M-$2M

Listing Activity

ACTIVITYNumber of listings

Market Average

Closing Performance

PERFORMANCECLOSE RATE

88%

Market Average

80%

Pricing Precision

PRECISIONList-to-Sale Price Ratio

100%

Market Average

100%

Speed To Sale

SPEEDDays on Market

11 Days

Market Average

9 Days

Cara Sheaffer’s Performance by City

Compare Cara Sheaffer’s performance to other agents based on price range and property type.

Chambersburg, Pennsylvania
ZIP: 17202
ZIP: 17201

Select a market segment:

All Property Types

Single Family Homes

Townhomes

Multi-family

All Price Ranges

$300k or less

$300k-$600k

Listing Activity

ACTIVITYNumber of listings

Market Average

Cara Sheaffer has sold 28 listings in Chambersburg. The market average for similar properties sold in this area is 2, meaning Cara Sheaffer has sold 14 times more properties than their peers.

Closing Performance

PERFORMANCECLOSE RATE

97%

Market Average

83%

Cara Sheaffer has a close rate of 97% for listings in Chambersburg. The market average for similar listings in this area is 83%, so Cara Sheaffer has closed 14% more listings than their peers.

Pricing Precision

PRECISIONList-to-Sale Price Ratio

99%

Market Average

100%

Cara Sheaffer closed listings in Chambersburg at 99% of the original listing price. That’s a drop of 1% from the original listing price. The market average in this area is 100%, meaning Cara Sheaffer drops the listing price by 1% more than other agents selling similar properties in this area.

Speed To Sale

SPEEDDays on Market

13 Days

Market Average

9 Days

Cara Sheaffer's average days on market for listings in Chambersburg is 13 days. The market average for similar properties is 9 days, meaning Cara Sheaffer closes listings 4 days slower than their peers.

Fayetteville, Pennsylvania
ZIP: 17222

Select a market segment:

All Property Types

Single Family Homes

Townhomes

All Price Ranges

$300k or less

$300k-$600k

$1M-$2M

Listing Activity

ACTIVITYNumber of listings

Market Average

Cara Sheaffer has sold 6 listings in Fayetteville. The market average for similar properties sold in this area is 1, meaning Cara Sheaffer has sold 6 times more properties than their peers.

Closing Performance

PERFORMANCECLOSE RATE

86%

Market Average

88%

Cara Sheaffer has a close rate of 86% for listings in Fayetteville. The market average for similar listings in this area is 88%, so Cara Sheaffer has closed 2% less listings than their peers.

Pricing Precision

PRECISIONList-to-Sale Price Ratio

100%

Market Average

100%

Cara Sheaffer closed listings in Fayetteville at the original listing price. The market average for similar properties is also 100% of the original listing price, meaning Cara Sheaffer has the same close rate as other agents selling similar properties in the area.

Speed To Sale

SPEEDDays on Market

8 Days

+25% faster

Market Average

10 Days

Cara Sheaffer's average days on market for listings in Fayetteville is 8 days. The market average for similar properties is 10 days, meaning Cara Sheaffer closes listings 25% faster than their peers.

Greencastle, Pennsylvania
ZIP: 17225

Select a market segment:

All Property Types

Single Family Homes

All Price Ranges

$300k or less

$300k-$600k

Listing Activity

ACTIVITYNumber of listings

Market Average

Cara Sheaffer has sold 2 listings in Greencastle. The market average for similar properties sold in this area is 1, meaning Cara Sheaffer has sold 100% more properties than their peers.

Closing Performance

PERFORMANCECLOSE RATE

67%

Market Average

70%

Cara Sheaffer has a close rate of 67% for listings in Greencastle. The market average for similar listings in this area is 70%, so Cara Sheaffer has closed 3% less listings than their peers.

Pricing Precision

PRECISIONList-to-Sale Price Ratio

89%

Market Average

100%

Cara Sheaffer closed listings in Greencastle at 89% of the original listing price. That’s a drop of 11% from the original listing price. The market average in this area is 100%, meaning Cara Sheaffer drops the listing price by 11% more than other agents selling similar properties in this area.

Speed To Sale

SPEEDDays on Market

40 Days

Market Average

13 Days

Cara Sheaffer's average days on market for listings in Greencastle is 40 days. The market average for similar properties is 13 days, meaning Cara Sheaffer closes listings 27 days slower than their peers.

Waynesboro, Pennsylvania
ZIP: 17268

Select a market segment:

All Property Types

Single Family Homes

Multi-family

All Price Ranges

$300k or less

Listing Activity

ACTIVITYNumber of listings

Market Average

Cara Sheaffer has sold 2 listings in Waynesboro. The market average for similar properties sold in this area is 2, meaning Cara Sheaffer's performance is the same as their peers.

Closing Performance

PERFORMANCECLOSE RATE

100%

Market Average

89%

Cara Sheaffer has a close rate of 100% for listings in Waynesboro. The market average for similar listings in this area is 89%, so Cara Sheaffer has closed 11% more listings than their peers.

Pricing Precision

PRECISIONList-to-Sale Price Ratio

82%

Market Average

100%

Cara Sheaffer closed listings in Waynesboro at 82% of the original listing price. That’s a drop of 18% from the original listing price. The market average in this area is 100%, meaning Cara Sheaffer drops the listing price by 18% more than other agents selling similar properties in this area.

Speed To Sale

SPEEDDays on Market

48 Days

Market Average

12 Days

Cara Sheaffer's average days on market for listings in Waynesboro is 48 days. The market average for similar properties is 12 days, meaning Cara Sheaffer closes listings 36 days slower than their peers.

Hagerstown, Maryland
ZIP: 21742
ZIP: 21740

Select a market segment:

All Property Types

Single Family Homes

All Price Ranges

$300k or less

$300k-$600k

Listing Activity

ACTIVITYNumber of listings

Market Average

Cara Sheaffer has sold 2 listings in Hagerstown. The market average for similar properties sold in this area is 2, meaning Cara Sheaffer's performance is the same as their peers.

Closing Performance

PERFORMANCECLOSE RATE

100%

Market Average

81%

Cara Sheaffer has a close rate of 100% for listings in Hagerstown. The market average for similar listings in this area is 81%, so Cara Sheaffer has closed 19% more listings than their peers.

Pricing Precision

PRECISIONList-to-Sale Price Ratio

95%

Market Average

100%

Cara Sheaffer closed listings in Hagerstown at 95% of the original listing price. That’s a drop of 5% from the original listing price. The market average in this area is 100%, meaning Cara Sheaffer drops the listing price by 5% more than other agents selling similar properties in this area.

Speed To Sale

SPEEDDays on Market

8 Days

+13% faster

Market Average

9 Days

Cara Sheaffer's average days on market for listings in Hagerstown is 8 days. The market average for similar properties is 9 days, meaning Cara Sheaffer closes listings 12.5% faster than their peers.

Listing History

Address

Details

Represented

Sell Date

211 HIGHLAND CIRCLE

Chambersburg

Single Family House

$265k | 3 BR | 2 BA

buyer

May 17, 2023

12 months ago

840 STOUFFER AVENUE

Chambersburg

Single Family House

$210k | 2 BR | 1 BA

seller

May 10, 2023

12 months ago

306 CHANNING DRIVE

Chambersburg

Townhouse

$195k | 3 BR | 2 BA

both

May 09, 2023

about 1 year ago

6 HOLLY COURT

Shippensburg

Single Family House

$290k | 3 BR | 3 BA

seller

April 27, 2023

about 1 year ago

221 BENEDICT AVENUE

Chambersburg

Single Family House

$250k | 3 BR | 2 BA

buyer

April 18, 2023

about 1 year ago

Have a question for Cara?

Let AgentStory connect you.